goTenna Mesh community

Best Battery for MOAN?

Building my first MOAN. Read everything I could find on this site, ready to launch … One question: I have a Voltaic v44 li-po (12,000 mAh) mobile device “power bank” that Im thinking about using to power the unit, along with a 9 watt solar panel.

I’ve noticed that most MOAN builders on the site are opting for AGM lead acid batteries. Are there advantages to lead acid batteries vs li-po for this kind of application?

That v44 lipo cell has a built in solar charge controller and has always-on capability, though it looks like there are some voltage limitations (you can’t plug a 12V or 18V solar panel in; all their panels are 6V or so). FYI you could probably get away with a smaller panel (the Watt-hour consumption of the Gotenna is pretty low).

One of the other options would be to get a dedicated solar charge controller with a separate lithium battery but I think the v44 solution is cleaner. This list was what I came up with before I noticed the v44 has this amazing feature. AGM batteries are cheaper but if they get discharged they completely shit the bed after a relatively short amount of time. The key advantage (and why people probably select them) is that there are a lot of solar charge controllers available for the 12V AGM voltage levels; lithium batteries have different voltage and charging characteristics and may explode if used with a regular 12V RV style charge controller. The charge controller in that shopping list is specifically modified for lithium use in the 3 cell configuration which is something like 11V nominal. From what I can tell that charge controller has minimal no-current draw with the integrated USB ports, but if you grab a cheap 12V to USB adapter off the internet they are likely to be pretty inefficient like just dumping the extra voltage with a regulator instead of using a higher quality DC-DC converter with the storage elements required to drop noise to an acceptable level.

I believe the OmniCharge battery packs have something similar (they can disable the auto-off), but one of the key things is that the v44 in “Always on” mode will shut off on a low battery power condition and then restart without intervention once enough solar has come in – I’m not sure how OmniCharge handles that. Not to mention the v44 is cheaper.

Wow. That was some fast feedback.

Hmm… I have a waterproof folding 21 watt panel that has an on-board 6 v regulator / controller (for charging phones & iPads).

Not ideal for mast mounting, but could lay it on the roof and hope that the panel size compensates for less-than-ideal orientation…

1 Like